Employee Underperformance? Check Who Is Leading Them First
Before you replace an employee for poor work, check their goals, feedback, workload, and manager. A founder's lesson on underperformance and leadership.
Before you replace an employee for poor work, check the conditions around that work. Employee underperformance is not always the employee's fault. Clear goals, useful feedback, enough time, and a capable manager all matter.
I have had to learn this as a founder.
It is easy to see a missed result and focus on the person who missed it. It is harder to ask whether I gave that person what they needed to succeed.
In 2026, I found myself talking about how much my view had changed. A strong person can struggle when the right leader is missing. Sometimes the frustration I felt toward the team should have sent me back to my own choices.
That does not remove the employee's responsibility. It adds mine.
How Can a Leadership Gap Look Like Poor Performance?
The work may arrive late. The quality may slip. A person may ask for approval on things they used to handle alone.
Those signs can mean several things. The person may lack a skill. They may have too much work. They may not know what matters most. Or their manager may be absent, unclear, or unable to coach them.
If you treat all those causes as the same problem, you will keep reaching for the same fix: find a new person.
A new hire may then enter the same weak setup. The name changes. The result does not.
What Should You Check Before Judging the Person?
I would start with four questions.
1. Did we define what good work looks like?
"Be more proactive" is not a clear goal.
A better request might be: review the account each Monday, flag the largest risk, and bring one next step to the team meeting.
That gives the person something they can do. It also gives the manager something fair to review.
Ask the employee to explain the goal in their own words. You may find that you have been working toward two different ideas of success.
2. Did we give feedback early enough?
A person cannot act on feedback they never received.
If a problem has bothered you for six weeks, but this is the first time you have named it, the employee has not had six weeks to fix it.
Use a recent example. Explain what happened, why it mattered, and what needs to change. Then check whether the next piece of work shows progress.
3. Does the workload fit the role?
People can look careless when they are switching between too many tasks.
Ask what they are working on, what keeps getting interrupted, and what they think comes first. Compare that with the priorities in your head.
If everything is urgent, you have not set priorities. You have passed the conflict to the employee.
4. Is someone actually leading them?
A manager's name on a chart does not mean coaching is happening.
Who reviews hard decisions? Who helps when a task is new? Who notices that a person is stuck before a deadline passes?
A team may hold things together through habit for a while. The gap becomes clearer when a strong manager leaves or the work gets harder.
How Do You Separate a Skill Gap From a Support Gap?
Use a small, clear piece of work to learn more.
Agree on the result. Show a good example. Give the person the tools and time they need. Set a review point before the final deadline.
Then watch what changes.
| What you observe | What it may suggest |
|---|---|
| Work improves after the goal is clear | The brief may have been the issue |
| Work improves with a few coached attempts | The person may need practice |
| Work improves when tasks are reduced | Workload may have been too high |
| The same issue remains despite support | Role fit or capability needs a closer review |
This is not a perfect test. It is a fairer way to gather evidence than judging from frustration alone.
What Should a Founder Say When Leadership Was Part of the Problem?
Say it plainly.
You might say: "I expected a result that I did not define well. Let's reset the goal and agree on how we will check progress."
That is a suggested way to start the conversation, not a line from a past meeting.
Owning your part does not mean saying all the work was acceptable. You can name a missed standard and admit that your guidance was weak.
I think that matters because founders set the tone for how a team handles mistakes. If I want people to face their part honestly, I need to do the same.
When Is Replacing Someone Still the Right Choice?
Sometimes the role and the person do not fit. Support does not erase every skill gap or repeated failure to follow through.
The point is to make that call from evidence.
You should be able to explain the standard, the support provided, the feedback given, and what happened next. That is very different from deciding that someone "just does not get it."
Follow your own fair review process and the rules that apply to your workplace.
FAQ
Is every performance problem a leadership problem?
No. But leadership is part of the system that shapes performance. Check it before ruling it out.
Does this mean lowering standards?
No. Clear goals and early feedback make standards easier to meet and enforce. Vague demands are not higher standards.
What if I am too busy to coach everyone?
Then the business may need stronger managers, fewer direct reports, or a narrower workload. A founder's lack of time does not make the need for guidance disappear.
How long should I give someone to improve?
It depends on the task, risk, and skill involved. Agree on a realistic review period and clear signs of progress. Avoid an open-ended promise or an arbitrary deadline.
The bottom line
One of the harder parts of building a business is learning that your first reading of a problem can be wrong.
I still expect good work. I also want to ask better questions before deciding why I am not getting it.
If a good person is struggling, look at who is leading them. That person may be you.
Keep reading
Pieces I've written on related topics that pair well with this one:
- How to Audit a Media Buyer Without Micromanaging, Most agency audits check ROAS and miss everything that matters. Here's the four-layer framework for auditing media buyer performance without micromanaging.
- How to Build a Paid Media Playbook a New Hire Can Run, Build a paid media playbook with clear decisions, account context, campaign intake, and review steps so new hires can work with less guesswork.
- What I Got Wrong About Hiring Media Buyers, Most media buyer hires fail because agencies optimize for platform skills instead of judgment, communication, and commercial thinking. The real framework.
- Your Media Team Will Hit Every Target You Set. That's the Problem., Performance marketing KPIs stop being useful the moment they become targets. Here is the test I run before assigning any number to a media buying team.
- Founding a Company at 25: What Impremis Taught Me, A personal reflection on entrepreneurial risk, decision-making, and what actually matters when building a company from scratch in your 20s. Lessons from Impremis.